Dale Yu: Review of Detective: Season One (Spoiler Free)

Detective: Season One

  • Designers: Ignacy Trzewiczek, Merry Nowak-Trzewiczek Weronika Spyra
  • Publisher: Portal Games
  • Players: 1-5
  • Age: 12+
  • Time: 90-120 mins
  • Played with review copy provided by Portal Games

TL;DR from the box – “Detective: Season One is a fully cooperative, deeply immersive, board game in which 1 to 5 players take on the roles of investigators trying to solve a crime. It consists of 3 stand-alone cases that can be played in around 90 minutes each. Each of the cases challenges players with different settings and case styles”.  The game is a descendant of the original Detective game from 2018.

  • Blood, Ink, and Tearsmoves the action to Great Britain, where players visit an old mansion and discover family secrets from the past that lead them to clues behind the mysterious death of the family patron. Fans of Agatha Christie’s novels will find themselves at home in this rather funny case!
  • Solid Alibi throws players in the middle of a bloody conflict between gangs and criminals in the Italian district. Players have to not only solve the crime and discover who killed Robert Parkson, but also witness growing tension in the district and find out who to trust in the spiral of violence and mutual accusations!
  • Natural Causestakes players to a university campus in the U.S. Professor Calvin Higgs is found dead in his lab at the Biology Institute of Virginia University. Players need to find out whether his death is from natural causes, or perhaps there’s someone in his surroundings responsible for this horrible crime. But what could be the motive?

In each story, the game board is placed on the table and the specific deck of cards for the chosen case is placed next to the board.  Each case has 24 cards – one cover card and 23 cards pertaining to the case.  The team will get a pool of Skill tokens to use during the case.  To finish the setup, refer to the specific page in the rules meant for the case you want to play.  Each player gets a Character tile, which have some roleplaying tips on one side, but functionally they are all the same.  Then log into the website built specifically for the game to start the game.  Read the introductory part of the story and get the first few Leads that you may choose to follow.

In order to understand how the game works, you must understand the three big concepts: Time, Clues, Locations.

TIME: Each case has a certain number of hours in which you need to solve the case. There is a time track on the board.  You spend time moving between locations as well as resolving certain cards.  The catch with the cards is that you’ll not know how long it takes to resolve a card until you’ve done the resolving!

CLUES: Clues will be found on Case cards and in the online database.  Both types of clues are identified with a number.

LOCATIONS: The gameboard shows the different locations where you can work on Leads. Move the team car to the new location and then spend an hour to travel between the spots.

The team works together here, discussing the information at hand and deciding what to do next. There are no individual turns here – players make a single decision for the team. There are 5 possible action options:

1] Follow a Lead – Draw Lead cards when specifically instructed; be sure to only read the front of a card.  Move the car icon and the timer if necessary.  Read the card aloud and follow any direct actions as written on the card.  You must follow the instructions on the card in top to bottom order.  Also, you you must finish the current Lead card before moving onto another card.  The card may lead you to access the website to read a particular lead.   You may also be given the option to Dig Deeper (more on this later).  Finally, if the card offers you Further Leads, write those possibilities down on some note paper as you may choose to follow these leads later.  Some Leads may require you to spend Skill tokens.  When you are done with the card, lay it to the right of the board to remind you that you can always read the front of the card.

2] Dig Deeper – As mentioned above, some Lead cards give you the option to Dig Deeper.  You may need to spend a Skill token to do this.  When you Dig Deeper, you flip over the current lead card and read more.  When you are done with the card, place it to the left of the board to remind you that you can access both sides of the card.

3] Browse the Database – If you are instructed to access the computer with NAME@, FILE@, QUESTIONING@, OTHER@ – log into your computer and read the things that you are asked to look at.  You may want to note this down on your note sheet in case you want to go back and read it again.  You should not try to guess at links, only look at them when you are instructed to find a specific file.

4] Take the Portrait – If you are instructed to gain a specific portrait, pull out the picture and you can now use it to organize your thoughts

5] Specific Actions for Cards and the Casebook –

You will use these actions as they make sense, and you will spend time as indicated on the cards and based on the movement of the team car.  When the timer reaches the 5 hours left space, the game asks players to Recap the Story and have a final brainstorming session to best use the limited time left.  When the timer moves to the final space, the case ends and the team logs into the computer to file their final report.  There will be a series of questions that need to be answered, and your final score is determined by the team’s answers to the questions. The computer will tabulate the scores and tell you if your team was successful enough to complete the case and therefore win the game!

My thoughts on the game

This new take on the Detective series is nice because it splits the story up into three discrete and easily playable cases.  Finding 90 minutes to fit in a case works for my group.  This game is much more free-form than a lot of other escape room / puzzle games that I’ve played – due in part to the use of the computer website for additional data.  It’s actually quite surprising how much story can be fit into just 23 double sided cards.

What is even more astonishing is that you will surely not have enough time to even read all 23 cards.  According to the designers, they estimate that the usual number of drawn cards is about a dozen – only half!  So, your team’s experience through a case could be vastly different from another team’s as you might have taken totally different paths to gain your information.

Like a real life detective story, there is no final “You Win” card – instead, there are various bits of information that you have to collect and then synthesize together to get to the solution. This open framework really causes the team to discuss all the information they have to try to make connections between the facts.

If this sounds interesting to you, there is a free print-and-play mini case to let you see how it works.

http://portalgames.pl/en/suburbia/    Even for people who own the game, it’s a really good way to learn how the game works so that you don’t make any procedural mistakes on the three real cases in the box!  Since you only get one shot at playing each – you really should understand how the rules work!  Anyways, it gives you another case to solve, so why not start with it?!

We chose to play this initial scenario as a way to familiarize ourself with the system, and because we thought that since this was being given away for free (you don’t even need to buy the game, you can scan the QR from the back of the box) – maybe it would be a bit easier and serve as a nice introductory game to learn the mechanics without using up our one chance at the three finished cases provided in the box.

So, my wife was gracious enough to print, cut and sleeve the 24 cards – which prevented any spoilers – are we sat down to play.  It plays just like the real cases, you still need a computer nearby to access the computer database.  As far as we could tell, this was a full on case.

The suggestion in the rules about taking notes?  That’s not a suggestion IMHO – that’s a must.  It’s frankly unbelievable the amount of information that you might want to remember.  Sure, you can always go back and look at the cards that you’ve already seen, but there’s so much stuff in the case that you will have a hard time even remembering what you need to.  Write it all down so that you can make the connections on your own.

There is a bit of an art with the timing.  You lose an hour each time you travel between locations, and while it doesn’t seem like a lot, I think you really might want to try to organize your investigations to minimize travel.  We might be completely off-base with this strategy though – it’s hard to tell only having one case under out belt, but that’s what we think for now…

The amount of detail in the story here is impressive.  In our case, the characters were referring to historical events, and when we Googled them, the dates/times/locations match up to reality.  Sure, this didn’t necessarily have to jive, but it does add a certain depth to the story that makes it richer and more believable.  Also, the quantity of information you can get is at times almost overwhelming.  But, I think this is a good representation of real detective work.  A detective isn’t going to learn just the facts; there’s gonna be a memory dump worth of things, and you have to sift through all the information to figure out which facts are useful, which facts are true, and which are un-necessary.  The same holds true here – you will end up reading A LOT of stuff, so be prepared for that.

We played with 4 players, and this felt right.  The facts are there in front of you, but it helps to have more people around to discuss what to do with those facts and how to build a coherent story from the facts in front of you.  We spent a few minutes between cards at times  going over the bits of information and throwing out theories about how those facts would fit into the different possible frameworks we had constructed for the crime.  This may not be the sort of game for everyone, but I enjoyed that exercise.

Our case took around 1hr 40 minutes, but we had to read the rules and get situated first, and this was our first game of Detective: Season 1, so there was a little bit of rules referencing as we got started.  Our group also spent a lot of time at a couple of junctures to try to develop the story.  As I mentioned earlier, I felt that this was very much like real detective work – I enjoyed the sifting through large amounts of data to try to figure out what was important.  Our group was able to come up with the full story as we answered all the questions correct at the end.  Our score was not perfect though as we did end up spending a bit of overtime as some of our investigations too a little longer than expected.  The story made sense and there weren’t any huge leaps of logical faith that sometimes plague other investigative games (Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective, I’m looking squarely at you here…)

For me, this was a good experience.  Maybe a little longer time-wise than I expected, but some of that was due to learning the rules and some of that was due to the fact that my group really spent a lot of time talking over the facts and theories.  Not everyone in my group loved it (or even liked it), but I can say that I’m still looking forward to trying out the three cases in the box.

I plan to report back later in the winter after we get the opportunity to play more, but I also wanted to get some first impressions out there as part of our SPIEL.digital coverage so that others can learn more about the game and decide if they want to try it as well.

Until your next appointment,

The Gaming Doctor

About Dale Yu

Dale Yu is the Editor of the Opinionated Gamers. He can occasionally be found working as a volunteer administrator for BoardGameGeek, and he previously wrote for BoardGame News.
This entry was posted in Essen 2020, First Impressions. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Dale Yu: Review of Detective: Season One (Spoiler Free)

  1. Mikel says:

    I thought suburbia was a demo case for the original detective, not season 1?

  2. paschott says:

    Suburbia was a demo for the original Detective. Bought the physical bits for that during PortalCon.

    Sounds like S1 is a bit more family-friendly. That’s intriguing to me. (and yes, there are still murders, but Clue also had murder) The original Detective was a little _too_ “adult” for me and the normal group we’d play with.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s