Designer Choice Selections: Hayashi, Henn, and Shinzawa

It’s our eighth day of presenting our favorite games from notable designers. Today’s group includes Hisashi Hayashi, Dirk Henn, and Taiki Shinzawa. A total of 55 people participated in the voting.

Hisashi Hayashi
Hayashi has probably had the most success of any Japanese designer in creating titles that have succeeded outside of his home land. His first game was String Railway, in 2009, and its extremely appealing and innovative gameplay signaled that this was a designer to watch. He has delivered on that promise and his game creations include an SdJ winner (Bomb Busters). He remains very productive.

I did a reasonable amount of grouping for Hayashi. I know that the two versions of Railway Boom have some significant differences, but they also have quite a bit in common, so I’m pretty comfortable grouping them together. The same is true of the two String Railway games and the two Trains titles. Hopefully, these all make sense. Here are Hayashi’s 10 highest rated designs:

1. Bomb Busters/Bomb Squad – 37
2. Yokohama – 31
3. Railway Boom (both) – 15
4. Trains/Trains: Rising Sun – 11
5. String Railway/String Railway: Transport – 7
6. Sail to India – 6
7. Minerva – 4
7. Rolling America/Rolling Japan – 4
7. Trick of the Rails – 4
10. Metro X/Voll verplant – 3

Two games dominated. Bomb Busters was a strong favorite to finish on top, but it’s pretty impressive that Yokohama, which is almost 10 years older, was able to make it as close as it did. Again, I think the fact that we have a veteran group of voters is a factor, since they’re no doubt familiar with what was Hayashi’s first major hit. I think the latest version of Railway Boom is a great game, but it hasn’t been out all that long, so getting over 10% of the total votes cast is quite respectable. Four games got double digit votes, 17 got at least one vote, and there was a total of 132 votes were cast.

Dirk Henn
Henn is next. He began as an independent designer/publisher during the early 90’s, literally selling copies of his games from his backpack during Essen fairs. Eventually, he developed a relationship with Queen, who ensured his designs reached a larger audience. He still releases a few games, but most of his work over the past 20 years has been redesigns of his older titles.

Like Hayashi, Henn has a number of groupings, mostly because many of his games were originally self-published and were then republished (usually with only a few changes) by Queen. Some of these grouping decisions deserve comment. I decided to group Showmanager and Atlantic Star together, despite the change in theme and artwork—they’re just too damn similar. Alhambra is grouped with New York, which, to the best of my knowledge, is simply a retheme. I chose, however, to keep Granada separate, because I think there were some differences introduced into it.

Only 12 of Henn’s games received votes. Here is the entire list:

1. Showmanager/Premier/Atlantic Star – 35
2. Alhambra/New York – 33
3. Wallenstein – 17
4. Metro/Iron Horse/Cable Car – 13
5. The Rose King/Texas – 8
5. Timbuktu – 8
7. Shogun – 6
8. Stimmt So/Alhambra Card Game – 4
9. Speculation – 3
10. Colonia – 1
10. High Tide – 1
10. The Gardens of the Alhambra/Carat – 1

Just as with Hayashi, two games of Henn’s games are the dominant ones. I imagine with most groups, Alhambra would have finished easily in first. But I know our voters go way back and Showmanager is such a superior 6-player middleweight that I figured it would do well and it wound up on top. Wallenstein was exceedingly popular back in the day (it was ranked as high as sixth on the Geek at one point, and Shogun got as high as eighth), so I thought it might do better. The decision to keep it and Shogun separate came only after some debate (they do have much in common), but even if we’d combined them, the total for the two games would have still left them in third place (although obviously closer to the top two). Henn’s games got a total of 130 votes.

Taiki Shinzawa
Shinzawa is the biggest specialist we’ve considered so far in this exercise. If you’re a lover of trick-taking games, you no doubt know his name, but many of you have probably never heard of him. Suffice it to say that he’s the designer of some of the most innovative and bizarre (in a good way) trick-takers around. The trick-taking boom began in Japan and he’s been a big part of it. He does design other kinds of games, but his biggest hits have been trick-takers. He’s been doing it for 15 years and continues to be very productive.

The groupings for Shinzawa are mostly due to the original Japanese versus the newer English language versions of many of his games. Usually, the two versions are quite comparable. Here are his top 10 games:

1. Maskmen – 11
2. Fives/The Green Fivura – 10
3. Ghosts of Christmas/Time Palatrix – 8
4. Big Top/Suroboruos – 6
4. Inflation!/Zimbabweee Trick – 6
4. Luz/Lumen – 6
7. 9 Lives/Catty – 4
8. American Bookshop – 3
8. Charms/Dois – 3
8. Quattro Trick-Taking – 3
8. Twinkle Starship/Segment Trix/Trick to the Future – 3

As you can see, the vote totals for Taiki are considerably lower than what we’ve seen from our other designers. A lot of our voters just weren’t familiar with his work. Only two of his games managed to reach double digits in votes. Maskmen wound up on top. Interestingly, it’s the only one of his top 6 games which has not been republished (and renamed) by an American publisher. It’s also one of his oldest games (the original version came out in 2014). Moreover, it’s the first instance where I haven’t had the chance to play a designer’s top ranked game. I have, however, played Fives and I think it’s terrific.

18 of Shinzawa’s games got at least one vote, but there were only a total of 74 votes cast for them, easily the lowest figure we’ve seen so far.

That finishes today’s discussion. The full vote totals for Hayashi and Shinzawa follow (we already listed all of Henn’s games). Tune in tomorrow, for a discussion of our favorite games from three new designers: Tony Boydell, Ryan Laukat, and Vladimir Suchy!

Hisashi Hayashi
1. Bomb Busters/Bomb Squad – 37
2. Yokohama – 31
3. Railway Boom (both) – 15
4. Trains/Trains: Rising Sun – 11
5. String Railway/String Railway: Transport – 7
6. Sail to India – 6
7. Minerva – 4
7. Rolling America/Rolling Japan – 4
7. Trick of the Rails – 4
10. Metro X/Voll verplant – 3
11. Across the United States – 2
11. Isaribi – 2
11. The Treasure Ship of Zheng He – 2
14. 5×5 City – 1
14. Level 10/Okey Dokey – 1
14. String Safari – 1
14. Yokohama Duel – 1

Taiki Shinzawa
1. Maskmen – 11
2. Fives/The Green Fivura – 10
3. Ghosts of Christmas/Time Palatrix – 8
4. Big Top/Suroboruos – 6
4. Inflation!/Zimbabweee Trick – 6
4. Luz/Lumen – 6
7. 9 Lives/Catty – 4
8. American Bookshop – 3
8. Charms/Dois – 3
8. Quattro Trick-Taking – 3
8. Twinkle Starship/Segment Trix/Trick to the Future – 3
12. 6 Forces – 2
12. No Loose Ends/Shut the Books – 2
12. Toppen/Tower of Babel – 2
12. Tower Chess – 2
16. A World Where Everything is a Little Kinder – 1
16. Can’t Win – 1
16. Cinderella’s Dance/Count Up 21 – 1

This entry was posted in Reviews. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply