Designer Choice Selections: Cathala, Friese, and Lehmann

Hey, everyone, hope you all had a great weekend. But we’re back to the work week and that means we continue with our Designer Choice series, where our group looks at three great designers and votes for our favorite games. Today, we’ll be checking out Bruno Cathala, Friedemann Friese, and Tom Lehmann. A total of 60 people participated in the voting.

Bruno Cathala
Cathala released his first games way back in 2002. Since then, he’s been one of the most productive and successful designers around, with a couple of SdJ awards to his credit.

Bruno co-designed 7 Wonders Duel and LotR: Duel for Middle-Earth with Antoine Bauza and, just as we did with Bauza, we decided not to group those two games together. We also decided to keep Mr. Jack, Mr. Jack Pocket, and Mr. Jack in New York separate.

We gave at least 4 votes to nine of Bruno’s games—here they are:

1. Kingdomino – 22
2. Five Tribes – 17
3. Sea Salt & Paper – 15
3. Shadows Over Camelot – 15
5. 7 Wonders Duel – 14
6. LotR: Duel for Middle-Earth – 10
7. Mr. Jack – 9
8. Cyclades – 5
9. Splendor Duel – 4

As you can see, there is no dominant game for Cathala. Instead, seven of his titles got at least 9 votes. It’s no surprise that the SdJ winning Kingdomino was our favorite of his designs. It’s probably an indicator of how productive Bruno has been over the years that we voted for a lot of his games—30 of them! Only Knizia (with 31) has had more so far. A bunch of those games have minimal support: 17 only received one or two votes. That speaks to a designer who consistently produces good and professionally designed games, but rarely hits it out of the park. Those 30 games got a total of 147 votes.

Bruno is known for working with one or more designers on his games, so it’s interesting that his top two titles are solo efforts. But all the other games we voted for are team efforts, so make of that what you will.

Another interesting split in the voting is to see what time period our favorite games came from. Of the 13 designs that got at least 3 votes, six of them were released in the 2005-2009 period, four (including 3 of the top 5) came out between 2014 and 2016, and three of them debuted between 2022 and 2024. Looks like 2014-2016 was kind of a golden period for Cathala (something I hadn’t realized until now), but perhaps the best conclusion we can draw is that this is a designer who has consistently created fine games over a 20 year period.

Friedemann Friese
Next on our list is Friese, the Man in Green. He’s been around since the early 90’s and I think it’s fair to say that no one designs games quite like him. Saying he thinks outside of the box doesn’t begin to describe it. He has maintained his popularity over the years and keeps giving us interesting games starting with the letter F.

Friedemann gave us some tough grouping decisions. The main issue was what to do with all the Power Grid games. First of all, we separated out Funkenschlag, which is to say, the original 2001 predecessor to Power Grid, the one that included crayon drawing. (I know that the German version of Power Grid is also called Funkenschlag, but we’ve gone with mostly English titles here.) 2004’s Power Grid is obviously derived from Funk, but the differences are pretty large, so I put Funk in its own category. Second, Power Grid: Factory Manager has almost nothing to do with Power Grid—it was just a branding strategy to bring eyeballs to a new design. The real decision was the choice to make Power Grid, Power Grid: Outpost, and Power Grid: The First Sparks separate games. Outpost changes quite a few fundamental rules and First Sparks is an introductory version of PG, so that was the justification. Hopefully, we weren’t being FFoolish. Finally, even though the two versions of Fresh Fish (from 1997 and 2014, respectively) do have some reasonably significant differences, we felt they were too much alike to separate, so we grouped them. We did the same thing with both versions of Free Ride.

After all that, let’s take a look at how we voted for Friedemann. Here are his top 10 games:

1. Power Grid – 39
2. Fresh Fish (both) – 15
3. Free Ride (both) – 12
4. Fearsome Floors – 10
4. Fishing – 10
6. Fauna – 8
7. Faiyum – 7
7. Friday – 7
9. Foppen – 6
9. Funkenschlag – 6

I’m sure no one is surprised to see Power Grid on top and by a very wide margin. I’m not sure what I would have predicted would have been Friese’s #2 game, but Fresh Fish probably wouldn’t have been it, even though it’s kind of the quintessential Friese game (even 30 years after its release, there’s really nothing else like it). Five of his games got double digit votes and 11 of them got at least 5 votes (Fische Fluppen Frikadellen is the eleventh). Just as with Cathala, we like a lot of Friedemann’s games at least a little—we voted for 32 of them, more than any other designer! 19 of those games got 3 or fewer votes. I’m not really sure exactly what that implies, other than that Friese is cranking out a lot of pretty good games. All told, 168 votes were cast for these games.

Friedemann’s games are fairly well distributed by date of publication. Like Cathala, his work appears to be consistent over time.

I was happy to see Faiyum, a personal favorite, get a top 10 finish. I was also happy to see FTW?! get 4 votes; I think there’s more to the game than many think and have had good luck introducing it to my game groups.

Tom Lehmann
Let’s end today’s article with Lehmann. He began by self-publishing his games in the early 90’s, starting with the gamer’s version of Monopoly, Fast Food Franchise. He moved into Eurogames and finally hit it big in 2007 with Race for the Galaxy. He remains active and popular to this day.

The only real grouping decision with Tom’s games was to combine To Court the King and Favor of the Pharoah. The latter is a fairly hefty redesign of the former, but fundamentally, they’re the same kind of game, so we grouped them together. Here are our top 10 games from Mr. Lehmann:

1. Race for the Galaxy – 39
2. Res Arcana – 22
3. Roll for the Galaxy – 19
4. 1846 – 15
5. To Court the King/Favor of the Pharoah – 10
6. Jump Drive – 8
6. New Frontiers – 8
8. Fast Food Franchise – 7
9. Dice Realms – 6
10. Phoenicia – 5
10. Roll Through the Ages: The Iron Age – 5
10. The City – 5

Again, there was no surprise to see Race on top of the list, by a wide margin. Res Arcana also topped 20 votes, and Roll for the Galaxy just missed. Five of his games got double digits in votes. 18 of his games got at least 1 vote and he received a total of 160 votes.

I looked at Tom’s early and late games, with the dividing point being 2010. The split for the games of his that got at least 3 votes is almost entirely even. His 7 early titles got a total of 78 votes; his 8 late games got a total of 78 votes. Can’t get much more balanced than that!

I was glad to see Phoenicia make the top 10. I think it’s an amazing game, but you rarely hear anything about it (its substandard production values certainly did it no favors). It seems our group of voters appreciates it, though.

Here are the full vote totals for all three designers. Check us out tomorrow, when we shine the spotlight on Mac Gerdts, Alexander Pfister, and Corne van Moorsel!

Bruno Cathala
1. Kingdomino – 22
2. Five Tribes – 17
3. Sea Salt & Paper – 15
3. Shadows Over Camelot – 15
5. 7 Wonders Duel – 14
6. LotR: Duel for Middle-Earth – 10
7. Mr. Jack – 9
8. Cyclades – 5
9. Splendor Duel – 4
10. Abyss – 3
10. Cleopatra and Society of Architects – 3
10. Dice Town – 3
10. Jamaica – 3
14. Animalia – 2
14. Boomtown – 2
14. Mr. Jack Pocket – 2
14. Queen’s Necklace – 2
14. The Little Prince: Make Me a Planet – 2
14. Trek 12 – 2
14. Yamatai – 2
21. Frosted Blooms – 1
21. Kanagawa – 1
21. Le Fantome de l’Opera – 1
21. Micropolis – 1
21. Mission: Red Planet (all) – 1
21. Orichalcum – 1
21. Scarabya – 1
21. Solstis – 1
21. SOS Titanic – 1
21. Wicked Witches Way – 1

30 games; 147 total votes

Friedemann Friese
1. Power Grid – 39
2. Fresh Fish (both) – 15
3. Free Ride (both) – 12
4. Fearsome Floors – 10
4. Fishing – 10
6. Fauna – 8
7. Faiyum – 7
7. Friday – 7
9. Foppen – 6
9. Funkenschlag – 6
11. Fische Fluppen Frikadellen – 5
12. FTW?! – 4
12. Fuji Flush – 4
14. Copycat – 3
14. Fabled Fruit – 3
14. Fast Sloths – 3
14. Findorff – 3
14. Finished! – 3
14. Power Grid: Factory Manager – 3
20. Fast Flowing Forest Fellers – 2
20. Funny Friends – 2
20. Power Grid: Outpost – 2
20. Power Grid: The First Sparks – 2
24. America – 1
24. Black Friday – 1
24. Famiglia – 1
24. Formidable Farm – 1
24. Fortress – 1
24. Futuropia – 1
24. Power Grid: The Card Game – 1
24. Stich-Meister – 1
24. Terra – 1

32 games; 168 total votes

Tom Lehmann
1. Race for the Galaxy – 39
2. Res Arcana – 22
3. Roll for the Galaxy – 19
4. 1846 – 15
5. To Court the King/Favor of the Pharoah – 10
6. Jump Drive – 8
6. New Frontiers – 8
8. Fast Food Franchise – 7
9. Dice Realms – 6
10. Phoenicia – 5
10. Roll Through the Ages: The Iron Age – 5
10. The City – 5
13. Pizarro & Co. – 4
14. 2038 – 3
15. Chu Han – 1
15. Dark Pact – 1
15. Res Arcana Duo – 1
15. Starship Merchants – 1

18 games; 160 total votes

This entry was posted in Reviews. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply