Today is our last article in our Designer Choice series. 30 designers in 10 days! And we end on a high note, as we vote for our favorites from Richard Breese, Rudiger Dorn, and Richard Garfield. 59 voters participated.
Richard Breese
Breese is an accountant (the name of his company is R&D Games) who decided to self-publish games in 1995. His called his first game Keywood and most of his subsequent designs include the word “Key” in their title. The Key games have been quite successful and he has continued to produce them.
The only grouping I did for Breese was to combine Aladdin’s Dragons, Keydom’s Dragons, and Keydom. The first two titles are pretty similar. Keydom, OTOH, has some definite differences from Aladdin’s. I honestly don’t know how many people have actually played Keydom (it was the second “Key” game and Richard wasn’t that well known when it came out), so I figured I’d group it with the other two.
15 of Breese’s designs got at least one vote, with a total of 119 votes. Here is how his top 10 games finished:
1. Keyflower – 28
2. Reef Encounter – 27
3. Keythedral – 14
4. Aladdin’s Dragons/Keydom’s Dragons/Keydom – 13
5. Key Flow – 8
6. Inhabit the Earth – 7
7. Keyside – 5
8. Key Harvest – 4
9. Key to the City – 3
9. Keyper – 3
9. Keywood – 3
We have two dominant games and I have to say, I didn’t see that coming. I figured Keyflower would be his top game by a wide margin, but it barely beat out Reef Encounter. Four games wound up with double figures in votes and two others had solid support.
There is definitely stronger support for Richard’s earlier games (up to, and including Keyflower) than the later ones. The top four games are all pre-2013. Of the listed games, there were almost as many later ones than early ones, but the pre-2013 titles got a total of 89 votes, while the later ones only received 26 votes. Even if you want to draw the line at 2010, the earlier titles got a few more votes than the later ones. Again, the surprising (to me) support for Reef Encounter is the big factor with this.
As a personal aside, Breese has certainly established a “brand” with his Key games. But one downside to that is it can be hard to remember which game is which when the titles are so similar. That’s been the case with me; I’ve enjoyed quite a few of them, but I do have a hard time keeping them all straight. The only Key game that really stands out for me is Key Flow, my favorite of the series. I was happy to see it finish fifth in the voting.
Rudiger Dorn
Dorn began releasing games in the early 90’s, but his career really took off starting in 2001. For the next half dozen years, he was one of the best designers in the world, with numerous hits and award winners. He then went into a bit of a slump, but reemerged with a vengeance in 2014, thanks to the KdJ winning Istanbul. He hasn’t produced much during the last five years, but I wouldn’t count him out.
Most of the groupings for Dorn’s games are fairly obvious ones. Here are his top 10 titles:
1. Goa – 35
2. Istanbul – 21
3. Las Vegas/Las Vegas Royale – 20
4. Louis XIV/Mafiozoo – 18
5. Jambo/Asante – 15
6. The Traders of Genoa – 10
7. Karuba – 9
8. Diamonds Club – 5
8. Emerald – 5
10. Luxor – 4
Goa takes the top spot pretty easily. Three of his games got at least 20 votes and four more got at least 9, showing how consistently good he’s been over his long career. I’m not surprised that the top two games wound up being Goa and Istanbul and, given that we’re dealing with a veteran group of voters, the greater support for 2004’s Goa isn’t a shock. I am a bit surprised, though, that Las Vegas (the game that Rick Thornquist once dubbed “Rudiger Dorn’s game of pure luck”) did as well as it did, but it did get an SdJ nomination and has maintained its popularity over the years. Louis and Jambo are two of Dorn’s classic designs from his Golden Period (both of them, along with Goa, came out during 2004-2005) and the vote reflected that.
Time-wise, early Dorn (say, before 2010) gets the “quality” nod (those games received a total of 91 votes, as opposed to 62 votes for the later titles), while late Dorn earns the “quantity” one (11 games from that time period got at least one vote, as opposed to only 7 early titles). The reason for this is easy to see; four of the top six games (including big winner Goa) were early ones, as were 7 of the top 11 (2006’s Arkadia finished eleventh). That makes a total of 18 Dorn games that got a mention; those games received 153 votes.
Richard Garfield
When 1993 dawned, Garfield was a college professor with an interesting idea for a game. By the end of the year, he was a millionaire and Magic: The Gathering had changed the gaming landscape forever. He has remained extremely active since then and must be considered one of the most influential designers of all time.
When I prepared Garfield’s ballot, I grouped Netrunner with Android: Netrunner. Since I’m not much of a CCG player, I wasn’t sure if this might represent blasphemy of some sort, but no one squawked. I also decided that it’s good to be the King, no matter what city, so I grouped the King of Tokyo, King of New York, and King of Monster Island games together. This group also includes all of the King of Tokyo games (there’s a lot of them), with the exception of King of Tokyo: Duel. Finally, I kept Bunny Kingdom and Bunny Kingdom Town as separate games.
The group wound up voting for 16 of Richard’s games, with a total of 141 votes. Here are his top 9 games:
1. Magic: The Gathering – 31
2. RoboRally (all) – 28
3. King of: Tokyo (all)/New York/Monster Island – 18
4. Android: Netrunner/Netrunner – 14
5. Magical Athlete – 13
6. Bunny Kingdom – 11
7. The Great Dalmuti/Dilbert – 10
8. Dungeons, Dice & Danger – 3
8. Mindbug (all) – 3
As you can see, Garfield is far from a one-trick pony. You might have thought that Magic would be the runaway winner, but it barely beat out RoboRally. There were a total of seven games with double digit votes, which is most impressive, but the votes drop off sharply after that.
I have to say, given the vast popularity of Magic (which continues to this day), I’m pretty shocked that it didn’t have a much bigger lead. I know that RoboRally was popular in its day, but M:tG is one of the most important games ever created, right up there with Settlers. Either we have fewer Magic fanatics among the voters than I would have thought or we feel that Mr. Garfield has had much more than one significant game creation during his career. Probably a little bit of both.
As a famous pig once said, that’s all folks! I hope you’ve enjoyed this insight into the best games of some of the best game designers in the world. Here are the full vote totals for today’s trio. Thanks for reading, everyone!
Richard Breese
1. Keyflower – 28
2. Reef Encounter – 27
3. Keythedral – 14
4. Aladdin’s Dragons/Keydom’s Dragons/Keydom – 13
5. Key Flow – 8
6. Inhabit the Earth – 7
7. Keyside – 5
8. Key Harvest – 4
9. Key to the City – 3
9. Keyper – 3
9. Keywood – 3
12. Aladdin’s Dragons Card Game – 1
12. Fowl Play! – 1
12. Keytown – 1
12. The BoardGameGeek Game – 1
Rudiger Dorn
1. Goa – 35
2. Istanbul – 21
3. Las Vegas/Las Vegas Royale – 20
4. Louis XIV/Mafiozoo – 18
5. Jambo/Asante – 15
6. The Traders of Genoa – 10
7. Karuba – 9
8. Diamonds Club – 5
8. Emerald – 5
10. Luxor – 4
11. Arkadia – 3
12. Il Vecchio – 2
13. Dragonheart/Opale – 1
13. Istanbul: The Dice Game – 1
13. Mercado – 1
13. Montana – 1
13. My Farm Shop – 1
13. Steam Time – 1
Richard Garfield
1. Magic: The Gathering – 31
2. RoboRally (all) – 28
3. King of: Tokyo (all)/New York/Monster Island – 18
4. Android: Netrunner/Netrunner – 14
5. Magical Athlete – 13
6. Bunny Kingdom – 11
7. The Great Dalmuti/Dilbert – 10
8. Dungeons, Dice & Danger – 3
8. Mindbug (all) – 3
10. Carnival of Monsters – 2
10. Half Truth – 2
10. KeyForge (all) – 2
13. Bunny Kingdom Town – 1
13. Final Titan – 1
13. King of Tokyo: Duel – 1
13. What Were You Thinking? – 1