We’re getting near to the end of our series where we pick our favorite games from notable designers. The Meeples Choice members had a few personal favorites they wanted to vote on, so I was happy to indulge them. They include Tony Boydell, Ryan Laukat, and Vladimir Suchy. This is more of a niche group than we’d been looking at earlier, so we only had 44 voters for them.
Tony Boydell
Boydell has been designing games since the turn of the century, but most gamers probably only became aware of him in 2012, when he released Snowdonia. He remains active, occasionally releasing games in his trademark quirky style.
12 of Tony’s games got at least one vote, with a total of 51 votes being made. Here is the entire list:
1. Snowdonia – 28
2. Guilds of London – 6
3. Totemo – 4
4. Paperclip Railways – 3
5. Alubari – 2
5. Ivor the Engine – 2
7. Aleph Null – 1
7. Bloody Legacy – 1
7. Foothills – 1
7. Fzzzt! – 1
7. Lux Aeterna – 1
7. Scandaroon – 1
I’m willing to believe that Boydell is more than a one-hit wonder, but you sure wouldn’t be able to tell from those results. The overwhelming winner is Snowdonia, by a far greater margin than any we’ve seen so far. Up until now, the game with the highest percentage of votes from their designer was Sackson’s Can’t Stop, which got 36% of all the votes cast for him. 55% of all of Tony’s votes went to Snowdonia! Guilds of London is far, far back in second place and only six of his games got as many as 2 votes. As far as our voters are concerned, it’s all Snowdonia, all the time!
Ryan Laukat
Laukat began as an illustrator and then switched to designing games, which he released through his company Red Raven Games. His first titles were Eight-Minute Empire and Empires of the Void in 2012. He has met with considerable success and a loyal following. He remains as active as ever.
Many of Ryan’s games have had sequels, so it was an easy decision to group them together. Our group gave votes to 15 of his titles, comprising 59 votes. Here are the vote totals for all of them:
1. Above and Below (both) – 13
2. Sleeping Gods (all) – 8
3. Eight-Minute Empire (both) – 6
4. Creature Caravan – 5
4. Near and Far – 5
4. Roam – 5
7. City of Iron (both) – 4
8. Artifacts, Inc. – 2
8. Islebound (all) – 2
8. Megaland – 2
8. Six Sojourns – 2
8. The Ancient World (both) – 2
13. Empires of the Void (I and II) – 1
13. Klondike Rush – 1
13. Now or Never – 1
Above and Below is the easy winner, finishing over Sleeping Gods, but it’s nothing like the level of dominance we saw with Snowdonia. Instead, the votes are far more evenly split. Seven of his games got at least 4 votes and twelve got at least 2 votes. Given that Laukat is basically self-published, it’s impressive that he has that many games which were known to our voters.
Vladimir Suchy
Suchy first game was League of Six, one of the first titles released by CGE in 2007. His early designs were well received, so he bet on himself, forming the company Delicious Games to release Underwater Cities. Needless to say, the bet was a very successful one and he continues to be very active.
The only games of Suchy’s I grouped were both versions of Shipyard, which, to the best of my knowledge, have few differences. Even though The Prodigals Club was derived from Last Will and The Prodigals Club, I felt strongly that they should be separate entries. 13 of Vladimir’s games got at least one vote—here they are:
1. Underwater Cities – 26
2. Last Will – 16
3. Pulsar 2849 – 11
4. Shipyard (both) – 8
5. Evacuation – 7
6. Praga Caput Regni – 6
6. Woodcraft – 6
8. 20th Century – 3
8. League of Six – 3
10. Epona – 2
10. Messina 1347 – 2
10. The Prodigals Club – 2
13. Resafa – 1
Once again, there’s a dominant game and there’s absolutely no surprise that it’s Underwater Cities. It has a big lead over Last Will, which also did very well. Pulsar 2849 also reached double figures, while four other games got at least 6 votes.
Even though Last Will has always been popular, I was still fairly surprised at the support it received. Praga, Pulsar, and Woodcraft all have higher Geek rankings and their average ratings are considerably higher. Weightwise, Last Will is easily the lightest of Suchy’s top 7; it’s also one of his oldest titles. So perhaps our voters found its weight appealing or they’ve just had more time to play it. Or maybe they just like a game about losing all their dough!
That’s all for today. Tomorrow, we’ll finish thing up, with three very intriguing and accomplished designers: Richard Breese, Rudiger Dorn, and Richard Garfield. If you’ve come this far, you can’t miss the finale!