Designer Choice Selections: Gerdts, Pfister, and van Moorsel

We’re back with another triplet of designers. Today, we’ll be discussing our favorite games from Mac Gerdts, Alexander Pfister, and Corne van Moorsel. A total of 58 people participated in the voting.

Mac Gerdts
There are very few instances where we know exactly who is responsible for a popular game mechanism. The rondel is one of them—it was created by Mac Gerdts (back in the 80’s, by his reckoning) and was first revealed to the world in a series of games released in the mid-00’s. Gerdts hasn’t designed too many games, but most of them have been very popular.

The grouping decisions for Gerdts were fairly straightforward. I grouped Antike and Antike II, but kept the 2-player version of the system, Antike Duellum, separate. Concordia and Concordia Venus were combined, as were Imperial and Imperial 2030. Finally, I decided to keep Transatlantic and Crossing Oceans separate.

That left Gerdts with only 10 games. As it turned out, no one voted for Antike Duellum, so here are Mac’s top 9 games:

1. Concordia/Concordia Venus – 40
2. Navegador – 24
3. Imperial/Imperial 2030 – 18
4. Antike/Antike II – 13
5. Hamburgum – 10
6. The Princes of Machu Picchu – 5
7. Transatlantic – 4
8. 7 Empires – 3
9. Crossing Oceans – 2

As expected, things weren’t too close. Concordia (which does not feature a rondel, but which is one of the first non-shuffling deckbuilders) won easily and Navegador also got a ton of votes. Three other games reached double digits, followed by a reasonably sharp fall off.

I’m a bit surprised that Imperial didn’t do better; it wouldn’t have shocked me if it had finished ahead of Navegador, so I wasn’t expecting it to trail by so many votes. (I’m very pleased by the result—I think Navegador is brilliant.) 7 Empires, Gerdts’ latest twist on the Imperial system, didn’t make much of an impact either; it’s possible that most of our voters haven’t had the chance to play it. I’m also a little surprised that Antike and Hamburgum did as well as they did. Then again, there’s was only 10 games on the ballot, so the votes had to go somewhere.

Alexander Pfister
Pfister is next. His first published game came in 2010. He started reasonably slowly, but really came into his own during a remarkable 2015, in which three of his games (Broom Service, Isle of Skye, and Mombasa) won major awards. He’s the co-designer of one of the most anticipated games from this Essen, so he’s still in his prime.

The only Pfister titles I grouped together were Mombasa and Skymines; there are a few differences between them, but they’re largely the same game, other than the change in theme. The main decision for Alex was whether or not to group together all the Great Western Trail games. There are four of them and I decided to keep them separate, since there are some reasonably big differences between them. There’s a case to be made to combine them, but that’s not how we went. At any rate, here are the vote totals for Pfister’s top 10 games:

1. Great Western Trail – 23
2. Isle of Skye – 18
3. Maracaibo – 14
4. Pirates of Maracaibo – 13
5. Mombasa/Skymines – 12
6. Port Royal – 11
7. Oh My Goods! – 10
8. Blackout: Hong Kong – 9
8. GWT: New Zealand – 9
10. Boonlake – 6
10. Broom Service – 6

GWT wins fairly comfortably, but I honestly expected it to be more dominant. The most obvious reason is that the vote was split among the different GWT titles. (If you sum the four Great Western Trail games together, they total 34 votes, which might be a more accurate reflection of how our voters view it, although I know there was at least one person who voted for multiple GWT games.) The rest of Alex’s games are quite tightly bunched, with nine games getting at least 9 votes, the most we’ve seen so far for any designer. Maracaibo did a bit better than I expected and Mombasa a bit worse. I was very pleased by the support given to Blackout: Hong Kong; I think it’s a great game, but you hardly ever hear about it. Overall, the result show a lot of appreciation for a significant number of Pfister games. 16 of his titles got at least 1 vote and his games got a total of 137 votes.

The other thing the vote confirms is that Pfister has done very well throughout his career with both heavier and lighter games. The dividing line between the two isn’t always clear, but I used the Geek’s complexity rating as a guide and found that we voted for 8 heavy and 8 light games and that the vote totals were 75 for the heavier titles and 62 for the lighter ones. Pretty even; the man is clearly capable of living in both worlds.

Corne van Moorsel
Younger readers might not recognize the name of this Dutch designer, but he’s been releasing interesting games through his company Cwali since 1998. For those of us who go back that far, he’s been a designer worth following for quite some time.

I made a lot of groupings for van Moorsel, since he’s done a lot of spinoffs of older designs over the years. I don’t think any of them are at all controversial. It still left us with a lot of games to vote on. Here are his top 9 titles:

1. Powerboats/Powerships – 20
2. Factory Fun/Factory Funner – 17
3. StreetSoccer/Champions 2020/Golden Goal – 14
4. Nova Luna/Habitats – 10
5. O Zoo le Mio/Zoosim – 9
6. BasketBoss – 8
6. Gipsy King – 8
6. Logistico – 8
6. Sun, Sea & Sand – 8

As with Pfister, the voting is quite concentrated. Where Alex had nine games with at least 9 votes, Corne had nine games with at least 8 votes. The gap between his top rated game and the ninth is unusually narrow.

van Moorsel is a niche designer and most of these games are around 20 years old, so this would have been a hard vote to handicap. Even given that, I find these results surprising. Nova Luna and Habitats are easily Corne’s top rated games on the Geek, so I would have expected them to do considerably better than they did. I only vaguely remember Powerboats, although I’m pretty sure I enjoyed it. I’m also mildly surprised that Logistico did as well as it did, although, again, I think it’s a solid game. The voters clearly have three favorite van Moorsel designs, but also like quite a few of his other ones. Overall, 23 of his games got at least one vote and a total of 132 votes were cast for him.

I was happy that two of my favorite van Moorsel designs, BasketBoss and Sun, Sea & Sand, tied for sixth.  BasketBoss is an excellent sports-themed game (Corne has specialized in such games over the years)–unfortunately, that makes it even more of a niche title.  Sun, Sea & Sand, though, is a superior middleweight that is very accessible; it deserves to be better known than it is.

That’s a wrap for today. The full vote totals for Pfister and van Moorsel follow (we already listed all of Gerdts’ games). Check us out tomorrow, when our three designers will have a decidedly Nipponese bent: Japan’s Hisashi Hayashi and Taiki Shinzawa, along with Dirk Henn (remember that one of his most popular games was called Shogun). See you then!

Alexander Pfister
1. Great Western Trail – 23
2. Isle of Skye – 18
3. Maracaibo – 14
4. Pirates of Maracaibo – 13
5. Mombasa/Skymines – 12
6. Port Royal – 11
7. Oh My Goods! – 10
8. Blackout: Hong Kong – 9
8. GWT: New Zealand – 9
10. Boonlake – 6
10. Broom Service – 6
12. Expedition to Newdale – 2
13. CloudAge – 1
13. GWT: Argentina – 1
13. GWT: El Paso – 1
13. The Mines of Zavandor – 1

Corne van Moorsel
1. Powerboats/Powerships – 20
2. Factory Fun/Factory Funner – 17
3. StreetSoccer/Champions 2020/Golden Goal – 14
4. Nova Luna/Habitats – 10
5. O Zoo le Mio/Zoosim – 9
6. BasketBoss – 8
6. Gipsy King – 8
6. Logistico – 8
6. Sun, Sea & Sand – 8
10. Isi/Morisi/Netzwerk – 4
10. Roll to the Top! – 4
10. Typo – 4
13. Floriado – 3
13. Samara – 3
13. Tweeeet – 3
16. Waddle – 2
17. Ab in die Tonne/Ocean Limbo – 1
17. Combi-Nations – 1
17. Exhibition: 20th Century – 1
17. Mayday! Mayday! – 1
17. Meltdown 2020 – 1
17. Mondriaan 2020 – 1
17. Titicaca – 1

This entry was posted in Reviews. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Designer Choice Selections: Gerdts, Pfister, and van Moorsel

  1. Chris Brandt says:

    Thanks, Larry! Pfister and Gerdts are two of my favorites and I enjoy a LOT of their games, including some of those that didn’t get a lot of votes. I didn’t know much about van Moorsel, but Basketboss is great. My group pulls it out every year for March Madness and we all play with multiple copies of the game. The second edition is slightly better, I think, but I’d never turn either one down if asked to play.

Leave a Reply