Review of Escape the Dark Castle – by Alan How

Escape the Dark Castle

 

  • Designed by Thomas Pike, James Shelton, Alex Crispin
  • Published by ThemeborneGames
  • Review copy provided by Themeborne Games
  • 8 plays so far
  • Review written by Alan How

Escape the dark Castle was the game that came out a last year ago from Themeborne games with little or no fanfare. With the vast number of Kickstarter produced games now it is easy to miss any individual games of course. It is now back with a new Kickstarter (ending on 30 June 2018), so Themeborne games are building on the success of their earlier kickstarter.

 

The game is a castle adventure game which is very easy to learn as well as easy to understand. A game can be set up extremely quickly so it’s good for newcomers to the hobby. Continue reading

Posted in Reviews | Leave a comment

SHARDS OF INFINITY

Designers: Gary Aran, Justin Gary

Publisher: Stoneblade/Ultra Pro

Players: 2-4

Age: 10+

Time: 30 minutes

Times played: 10, with a copy I purchased

                                                              img_20180624_183920342

The first time I was introduced to a game with card interaction as its sole mechanism it was very early in my board gaming experience as an adult, and the person teaching it to me was so excited about the game (Magic the Gathering) that he had to tell me about every possible interaction, every possible card, every situation it could be used in and how eighteen other cards would be better and then just play cards for me; I quickly became overwhelmed and disinterested in playing this type of game again. Flash forward to a few years later, when I was the only person not involved in a game, so two friends invited me to play MtG. They were both shocked that I had only tried it once and found it too complicated and confusing and one offered to be my “coach” and play as a team. Well, he (Craig Massey – thanks, Craig!) did a terrific job of explaining the game, telling me only what I needed to know at the time and letting me discover some combinations for myself and I was hooked. Deck-building is now one of my favorite mechanics.  While browsing new game releases looking for a birthday gift for my husband (also a deckbuilding fan) I came across Shards of Infinity.

The game comes with a deck of 88 cards, 40 starter deck cards (10 for each player) and four character cards. Each player gets the same starter deck of 10 cards and a character card.   Your character card includes two wheels that track health and mastery.

                                         

img_20180624_1533042401

Starting Hand

img_20180624_150936115

Character Card

 

All players draw 5 cards from their deck. All players except the first player also start with at least one mastery point (dependent on the number of players). Six cards from the deck are flipped face up and the game begins. Each turn consists of three phases, but before we get to that let’s talk about the cards in that face-down deck. There are 3 types of cards.

        img_20180624_1528535101

                                                       

Ally Cards can be recruited by paying their cost in gems (upper right corner); you put them into your discard pile. When you play the Ally card, you get the effect listed on the bottom of the card; some effects may have additional conditions that need to be met. At the end of your turn Ally Cards are discarded to your discard pile.

img_20180624_220121694

                                                       

Mercenary Allies can also be recruited, just like a regular Ally card, but you also have another option – you can choose to fast-play the mercenary. To do so you pay the cost of the card and then immediately gain the effect listed; at the end of the turn any fast-played mercenaries are returned to the bottom of the draw deck.

                                                      img_20180624_1515543061 

Champions are recruited just like Ally Cards. However, once you draw and play a Champion it will stay in play until it has been damaged or destroyed. You can use a  Champion’s ability once per turn; you exhaust it once used and then reset it for future use at the end of your turn.

img_20180624_152201016

All types of cards may allow you to amp up the effect if you have a certain Mastery level – doubling your money or your damage, gaining back health etc. The amount of mastery needed is indicated on the card.

The first phase is the Play Phase. Players may do any or all of the following actions in any order:

  • Play cards from your hand; any number of cards can be played
  • Exhaust played Champions to gain their effects
  • Recruit Allies/Champions and put them into your discard pile.  You recruit them from the face-up display of six in the middle of the table; cards are replaced immediately when bought.
  • Fast-play Mercenary Allies; recruit them from the face-up display of six in the middle of the table; cards are replaced immediately when bought
  • Spend one gem to gain one Mastery (only once per turn)
  • Use power to destroy Champions,

The second phase is the Attack Phase. You use any remaining power (the red symbols) to attack your opponents; damage may be directed to one or more opponents in any combination. After damage is assigned, attacked players may reveal shields from their hands to prevent that number of damage. Any remaining damage is then inflicted; the damaged player reduces their health by that number of damage.

The third phase is the End Phase. The following actions are taken in order:

  • Put any fast-played Mercenary Allies on the bottom of the deck.
  • Put any other played Allies into your discard pile.
  • Put any unplayed cards from your hand into your discard pile.
  • Draw 5 cards.

Play continues until all players but one have zero health and the remaining player wins.

MY THOUGHTS ON THE GAME

The components of the game are of good quality; the cardstock is good and the character wheels are easy to use. The game comes in a fairly small box that is just a bit larger than 2 decks of cards.

The rules are well-written and clear; we went from rules to playing in 5 minutes, and we have not had any unresolved rules questions. There is a helpful FAQ at the end of the rules that we did reference a few times, as well as a glossary.

The theme of the game is fantasy, but doesn’t really add to or detract from the game. There is some flavor text on the cards.

How is this game different from the numerous other deckbuilders out there? Well, it’s not terribly different, really. It has one mechanism that I haven’t seen before (the Mercenary Ally), but it’s the same sort of ideas as many other games I enjoy – develop, maintain and enhance your hand for the best card combinations.  A game doesn’t have always to recreate the wheel for me to like it, though; I generally like deckbuilders, and I like this game quite a bit. All of the cards have an effect that is freestanding, but building up the right combos of cards to take advantage of the better effects leads to some really fun turns (well, maybe not so fun for your opponent). You can slowly build up your Mastery so you can do more damage or gain more benefits, but an opponent could be taking you down with strong card combinations while you do that, so you have to balance your efforts.  

The Mercenary Ally is an interesting mechanic;  Balancing delayed gratification with immediate results makes for some interesting choices.  I eschewed this strategy at first, thinking it was a waste of money for one use, but that is often not the case – it is an interesting mechanic. If you aren’t drawing the card you need or are in a desperate situation it gives you a way to address it.

In addition, I found the fact that you could learn/teach it quickly and play it quickly to be a positive, too; this would make a good filler that is more game than activity, which in my opinion many “filler” games are.

I do wish the Character cards each had a special power or ability; while the art on them is different, they are functionally all the same.

After our first couple of games our average game time has been 15 minutes with two players, which is great- you can play it again or use it as a quick filler.

This is a solid deckbuilder with interesting choices and definite replaybility. I expect it to see many more plays in the coming months.

Ratings from the Opinionated Gamers:

I love it!  

I like it. Tery

Neutral.

Not for me

Posted in Reviews | 1 Comment

2017 Meeples Choice Award Winners

The voting for the Meeples Choice Awards has ended and the following three games were chosen by the Spielfrieks user group:

AZUL
HEAVEN & ALE
GAIA PROJECT

The first two games were designed (or co-designed) by Michael Kiesling, making him only the second designer to have two MCA awards in one year (Reiner Knizia is the only other one, having accomplished it in both 1998 and 1999).  Remarkably, it’s Kiesling’s first MCA awards; the same is true of his Heaven & Ale co-designer, Andreas Schmidt. It’s the second award for Gaia Project’s designers, Jens Drogemuller and Helge Ostertag, as they both won earlier for Terra Mystica.  Speaking of Knizia, he barely missed earning his 11th Meeples Choice Award for The Quest for El Dorado–it fell just one vote short.

Here are the vote totals for all the nominated games.  The first figure is the votes received during the final round, while the second figure (in parentheses) is the vote total during the preliminary round, which determined the nominations.  Congratulations to all the winning games!

  1.  Azul – 21  (25)
  2.  Heaven & Ale – 13  (26)
  3.  Gaia Project – 12  (16)
  4.  The Quest for El Dorado – 11  (17)
  5.  Clans of Caledonia – 10  (19)
  6.  Jump Drive – 10  (15)
  7.  Nusfjord – 10  (13)
  8.  Altiplano – 10  (12)
  9.  The 7th Continent – 10  (7)
  10.  Lisboa – 8  (11)
  11.  Magic Maze – 7  (12)
  12.  Rajas of the Ganges – 7  (12)
  13.  Gloomhaven – 7  (11)
  14.  Photosynthesis – 7  (8)
  15.  Gentes – 6  (12)
  16.  Sagrada – 6  (9)
  17.  Charterstone – 6  (8)
  18.  Pulsar 2849 – 5  (13)
  19.  Keyper – 5  (10)
  20.  Barenpark – 5  (8)
  21.  Dinosaur Island – 5  (7)
  22.  Codenames Duet – 4  (13)
  23.  NMBR 9 – 4  (9)
  24.  Ethnos – 4  (8)
  25.  Sidereal Confluence – 4  (7)
  26.  Riverboat – 3  (8)
  27.  Santa Maria – 2  (7)

 

Posted in Reviews | Leave a comment

Dale Yu: Review of Mafiozoo

 

Mafiozoo

  • Designer: Rudiger Dorn
  • Publisher: Super Meeple / Surfin’ Meeple
  • Players: 2-4
  • Age: 12+
  • Time: 60-75 minutes
  • Times played: 4, with review copy provided by Surfin’ Meeple

 

In Mafiozoo, players are vying to be the next member of Wally Longtooth’s gang by gaining the most influence over important members of the local anthropomorphic crime network. The game is a revision of an old classic, Louis XIV.   While I was at first unsure whether Louis XIV needed a new version, discussion amongst some local gamers has shown me that there are many gamers new to the hobby who haven’t had the chance to play the original version. For a quick review of the original game, let me point you to a review written by the OG’s resident Dorn fanboy, Larry Levy: https://boardgamegeek.com/thread/133466/louis-xiv-my-designer-king-does-sun-king    (It will be helpful to be a little familiar with the first version as some of this review will be referencing likenesses and differences from that version.

Continue reading

Posted in Reviews | Leave a comment

James Nathan: Short Origins Trip

My yearly convention calendar is ever-evolving, with BGG.CON a lock, and others coming and going. Origins and Gen Con are both a short drive for me, but aren’t sufficiently enticing to draw me up that I block out time for them.  If as the time approaches the stars align, then I may pop up for a day.  There was a syzygy for Saturday, so I went up with a friend and her stepdaughter – who casually play games (when I bring them over), but were 1-1 on having been to something like Origins before.  My roll was largely personal concierge and game sommelier.

They were up for anything –one of the joys of attending cons with folks less jaded and cynical than myself– including a departure time from Cincinnati of 2 hours earlier than they had suggested, and parking, well, here’s where I park for Origins.

origins

There’s free street parking and an immediate highway entrance after it’s over. Also, it’s by this park where we saw an albino squirrel. Continue reading

Posted in Convention Report | 4 Comments

Patrick Brennan: Game Snapshots – June 2018 (Part 2)

Patrick Brennan: Game Snapshots – June 2018 (Part 2)

Mel has been known to stop by at Patrick’s game nights. He has a great trick to escape from a straightjacket.

I’ve been recently thinking about the preponderance of 7’s in my world. I started euro-gaming in 1999 when new-game junkies like myself just had to suck up whatever came, the good and the bad, to get their hit. There weren’t 100+ new good games each year (which is what I’ve averaged), so our ratings were more varied.

These days we know average ratings are rising because of selection bias. You can spend all your gaming time playing just those games you like and love without having to resort to  games that aren’t your thing for the sake of variety – which means that the low ratings for such that might have been generated in the past (when they were played for variety’s sake) aren’t being generated as much anymore. Hence the rising rating levels. Continue reading

Posted in Commentary | Leave a comment